[James Bryce, Viscount Bryce - born May 10, 1838, Belfast, Ireland - died January 22, 1922, Sidmouth, Devon, England.
British politician, diplomat, and historian best known for his highly successful ambassadorship to the United States
(1907-13) and for his study of the U.S. Constitution.
After his education at the Univ. of Glasgow and at Oxford, he practiced law in London for a short time before becoming
professor of civil law at Oxford. He wrote significant works in several fields; the first of these was his History of the
Holy Roman Empire (1864). He entered politics and became a leader of the Liberal party, occupying a variety of posts,
including the presidency of the Board of Trade and the chief secretaryship of Ireland. His interest in sociology and
philosophy is evident in the second of his great treatises. The American Commonwealth (1888), a classic that is still read
and used. Bryce was ambassador to the United States from 1907 to 1913; he was one of the most popular ever to be in
Washington, since his knowledge of Americans, as revealed in his writings, was profound. He was created a peer in 1914.
His other major works are Studies in History and Jurisprudence (1901) and Modern Democracies (1921).]
Documents presented to
VISCOUNT GREY OF FALLODON
Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs
By Viscount Bryce
With a preface by
VISCOUNT BRYCE
LONDON:
PRINTED UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF HIS MAJESTY'S
STATIONERY OFFICE
By SIR JOSEPH CAUSTON AND SONS, LIMITED,
9, EASTCHEAP, E.C.
To be purchased, either directly or through any Bookseller.
from
WYMAN AND SONS, LIMITED, 29, BREAMS BUILDINGS,
FETTER LANE, E.C.,
and 54, ST. MARY STREET, CARDIFF; or
H.M. STATIONERY OFFICE (SCOTTISH BRANCH),
23, FORTH STREET, EDINBURGH ; or
E. PONSONBY, LIMITED, 116, GRAFTON STREET, DUBLIN:
or from the Agencies in the British Colonies and Dependencies,
the United States of America and other Foreign Countries of
T. FISHER UNWIN, LIMITED, LONDON, W.C.
1916.
Price Two Shillings
CORRESPONDENCE BETWEEN VISCOUNT GREY OF FALLODON
Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs
AND
VISCOUNT BRYCE.
LETTER FROM VISCOUNT BRYCE TO VISCOUNT GREY OF FALLODON, SECRETARY OF STATE FOR FOREIGN AFFAIRS.
July 1st, 1916.
MY DEAR SIR EDWARD,
In the autumn of 1915 accounts of massacres and deportations of the Christian population of Asiatic Turkey began to reach Western Europe and the United States. Few and imperfect at first---for every effort was made by the Turkish Government to prevent them from passing out of the country---these accounts increased in number and fullness of detail, till in the beginning of 1916 it became possible to obtain a fairly accurate knowledge of what had happened. It then struck me that, in the interest of historic truth, as well as with a view to the questions that must arise when the war ends, it become necessary to try to complete these accounts, and test them by further evidence, so as to compile a general narrative of the events and estimate their significance. As materials were wanting or scanty in respect of some localities, I wrote to all the persons I could think of likely to possess or to be able to procure trustworthy data, begging them to favour me with such data. I addressed myself in particular to friends in the United States, a country which has long had intimate relations with the Eastern Christians and to which many of those Christians have in recent years emigrated. Similar requests were made to Switzerland, also a neutral country, many of whose people have taken a lively interest in the welfare of the Armenians. When the responses from these quarters showed that sufficient materials for a history---provisional, no doubt, but trustworthy as far as the present data went---could be obtained, I had the good fortune to secure the co-operation of a young historian of high academic distinction, Mr. Arnold J. Toynbee, late Fellow of Balliol College, Oxford. He undertook to examine and put together the pieces of evidence collected, arranging them in order and adding such observations, historical and geographical, as seemed needed to explain them. The materials so arranged by Mr. Toynbee, followed by such observations as aforesaid, I now transmit to you. They are, of course, of unequal value, for while most of them are narratives by eyewitnesses, some few report at second hand what was told by eye-witnesses. In a short introduction prefixed, I have tried to estimate their value, and so need only say here that nothing has been admitted the substantial truth of which seems open to reasonable doubt. Facts only have been dealt with ; questions of future policy have been carefully avoided.
It is evidently desirable not only that ascertained facts should be put on record for the sake of future historians, while the events are still fresh in living memory, but also that the public opinion of the belligerent nations---and, I may add, of neutral peoples also---should be enabled by a knowledge of what has happened in Asia Minor and Armenia to exercise its judgment on the course proper to be followed when, at the end of the present war, a political re-settlement of the Nearer East has to be undertaken.
I am,
Yours sincerely,
BRYCE.
LETTER FROM VISCOUNT GREY OF FALLODON, SECRETARY OF STATE FOR FOREIGN AFFAIRS, TO VISCOUNT BRYCE.
Foreign Office,
August 23rd, 1916.
MY DEAR BRYCE,
I have to thank you for sending me the collection of documents on the Armenian Massacres which has been so ably put together by Mr. Arnold J. Toynbee.
It is a terrible mass of evidence; but I feel that it ought to be published and widely studied by all who have the broad interests of humanity at heart. It will be valuable, not only for the immediate information of public opinion as to the conduct of the Turkish Government towards this defenceless people, but also as a mine of information for historians in the future, and for the other purposes suggested in your letter.
Yours sincerely,
GREY OF FALLODON.
Documents presented to
VISCOUNT GREY OF FALLODON
Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs
By Viscount Bryce
With a preface by VISCOUNT BRYCE.
In the summer of 1915 accounts, few and scanty at first, but increasing
in volume later, began to find their way out of Asiatic Turkey as to the
events that were happening there. These accounts described what seemed to
be an effort to exterminate a whole nation, without distinction of age or
sex, whose misfortune it was to be the subjects of a Government devoid of
scruples and of pity, and the policy they disclosed was one without precedent
even in the blood-stained annals of the East.
It then became the obvious duty of those who realised the gravity of these events to try to collect
and put together all the data available for the purpose of presenting a
full and authentic record of what had occurred. This has been done in the
present volume. It contains all the evidence that could be obtained up till
July 1916 as to the massacres and deportations of the Armenian and other
Eastern Christians dwelling in Asia Minor, Armenia and that north-western
corner of Persia which was invaded by the Turkish troops. It is presented
primarily as a contribution to history, but partly also for the purpose
of enabling the civilised nations of Europe to comprehend the problems which
will arise at the end of this war, when it will become necessary to provide
for the future government of what are now the Turkish dominions. The compilation
has been made in the spirit proper to an historical enquiry, that is to
say, nothing has been omitted which could throw light on the facts, whatever
the political bearing of the accounts might be. In such an enquiry, no racial
or religious sympathies, no prejudices, not even the natural horror raised
by crimes, ought to distract the mind of the enquirer from the duty of trying
to ascertain the real facts.
As will be seen from the analysis which follows, the evidence here collected comes from various sources.
A large, perhaps the largest, part has been drawn from neutral witnesses who were living in or passing through Asiatic
Turkey while these events were happening, and had opportunities of observing them.
Another part comes from natives of the country, nearly all Christians, who succeeded, despite the stringency of the Turkish
censorship, in getting letters into neutral countries, or who themselves escaped into Greece, or Russia, or Egypt and were
there able to write down what they had seen.
A third but much smaller part comes from subjects of the now belligerent Powers (mostly Germans) who were in Turkey when
these events were happening, and subsequently published in their own countries accounts based on their personal knowledge.
In presenting this evidence it has been necessary in very many cases to withhold the names of the witnesses, because to
publish their names would be to expose such of them as are still within the Turkish dominions, or the relations and friends
of these persons, to the ruthless vengeance of the gang who now rule those dominions in the name of the unfortunate Sultan.
Even in the case of those neutral witnesses who are safe in their own countries, a similar precaution must be observed,
because many of them, or their friends and associates, have property in Turkey which would at once, despite their neutral
character, be seized by the Turkish Government. These difficulties, inevitable in the nature of the case, are of course only
temporary. The names of the great majority of the witnesses are known to the editor of this book and to myself, and also to
several other persons, and they can be made public as soon as it is certain that no harm will result to these witnesses or
to their friends. That certainty evidently cannot be attained till the war is over and the rule of the savage gang already referred to has come to an end.
The question now arises---What is the value of this evidence? Though
the names of many of the witnesses cannot be given, I may say that most
of them, and nearly all of those who belong to neutral or belligerent countries,
are persons entitled to confidence in respect of their character and standing,
and are, moreover, persons who have no conceivable motive for inventing
or perverting facts, because they are (with extremely few exceptions) either
neutrals with no national or personal or pecuniary interests involved, or
else German subjects. Were I free to mention names, the trustworthiness
of these neutrals and Germans would at once be recognised.
Let us, however, look at the evidence itself.
(i) Nearly all of it comes from eye-witnesses, some of whom wrote it down themselves, while others gave it to persons who wrote it out at the time from the statements given to them orally. Nearly all of it, moreover, was written immediately after the events described, when the witnesses' recollection was still fresh and clear.
(ii) The main facts rest upon evidence coming from different and independent sources. When the same fact is stated by witnesses who had no communication with one another, and in many cases did not even speak the same language, the presumption in favour of its truth becomes strong.
Take, for instance, the evidence regarding the particularly terrible events at Trebizond. We have a statement
from the Italian Consul-General, from the Kavass of the local branch of the Ottoman Bank, a Montenegrin under
Italian protection, and from an Armenian girl whose family lived in the neighbourhood of the Italian Consulate, and
who was brought out of Turkey by the Italian Consul-General as his maid servant. The testimony of these three witnesses
exactly tallies, not only as to the public crimes committed in the city before they left it, but also
as to their personal relations with one another (for they each mention on
the others explicitly in their several statements). Yet they were in no
touch whatever with one another when their respective testimonies were given.
The Consul-General gave his at Rome, in an interview with an Italian journalist;
the Kavass gave his in an interview with an Armenian gentleman in Egypt;
and the girl hers in Roumania to a compatriot resident in that country.
The three statements had certainly never been collated till they came, by
different channels, into the hands of the editor of this book. In addition
to this, there is a statement from another foreign resident at Trebizond, which reached us through America.
Or take the case of the convoys of exiles deported from the Vilayet of Erzeroum, and, in particular, from the towns of
Erzeroum and Baibourt. We have a second-hand account of their fate in Doc. 2, a despatch from a well-informed source at
Constantinople; we have a first-hand account, which completely bears out the former, from a lady who was herself deported in
the third convoy of exiles; we have the narrative of two Danish nurses in the service of the German Red Cross at Erzindjan,
who witnessed the passage of the Baibourt exiles through that place and finally
there are three witnesses from the town of H., several days' journey further
along the exiles' route, who refer independently to the arrival of convoys
from Erzeroum and the neighbourhood. One of these latter witnesses is a
(third) Danish Red Cross nurse, one a neutral resident at H. of different nationality, and one an Armenian inhabitant of the town.
These are two typical instances in which broad groups of events are independently and consistently recorded, but there are
innumerable instances of the same kind in the case of particular occurrences. The hanging of the Armenian Bishop of
Baibourt, for example, is mentioned, at second-hand, in Doc. 7 (written at Constantinople) and Doc. 12 (a selection of
evidence published in Germany); but it is also witnessed to by the author of Doc. 59, an actual resident at Baibourt who was
present there at the time of the murder. Again, the disappearance of the Bishop of Erzeroum on the road to exile
is not only recorded in Doc. 11, a memorandum from a competent source at Bukarest, but is confirmed, in Docs. 57 and 76, by
testimony obtained from eye-witnesses on the spot after the Russian occupation of Erzeroum had left them free to speak out.
(iii) Facts of the same, or of a very similar, nature occurring in different
places, are deposed to by different and independent witnesses. As there
is every reason to believe ---and indeed it is hardly denied---that the
massacres and deportations were carried out under general orders proceeding
from Constantinople, the fact that persons who knew only what was happening
in one locality record circumstances there broadly resembling those which
occurred in another locality goes to show the general correctness of both sets of accounts.
Thus, the two Danish Red Cross nurses (Doc. 62) state that they twice witnessed the massacre, in cold blood, of gangs of
unarmed Armenian soldiers employed on navvy work, along the road from Erzindjan to Sivas. In Doc. 7 (written at
Constantinople) we find a statement that other gangs of unarmed Armenian soldiers were similarly murdered on the roads
between Ourfa and Diyarbekir, and Diyarbekir and Harpout; and the massacre on this latter section of road is confirmed by a
German lady resident, at the time, at Harpout (Doc. 23).
Again, there is frequent mention of roads being lined, or littered, with the corpses of Armenian exiles who had died of
exhaustion or been murdered on the way. If these allusions were merely made in general terms, they might conceivably be
explained away as amplifications of some isolated case, or even as rhetorical embellishments of the exiles' story without
foundation in fact. But when we find such statements made with regard to particular stretches of road in widely different
localities, and often by more than one witness with regard to a given stretch, we are led to infer that this
wholesale mortality by the wayside was in very deed a frequent concomitant
of the Deportations, and an inevitable consequence of the method on which
the general scheme of Deportation was organised from headquarters. We hear
in Doc. 7, for instance, of corpses on the road from Malatia to Sivas, on the testimony of a Moslem traveller; we hear of
them on the road from Diyarbekir to Ourfa in Doc. 12
(a German cavalry captain), and on the road from Ourfa to Aleppo in Doc. 9 (an Armenian witness), in
Doc. 135 (an interned Englishwoman), and also in Doc. 64 (a Danish Red Cross nurse). The latter gives the detail of
the corpses being mangled by wild beasts, a detail also mentioned by the German authors of Docs. 12 and 23. Similar testimony
from German officers regarding the road between Baghdad and Aleppo is reported independently in Docs. 108 and 121.
(iv) The volume of this concurrent evidence from different quarters is
so large as to establish the main facts beyond all question. Errors of detail
in some instances may be allowed for. Exaggeration may, in the case of native
witnesses, who were more likely to be excited, be also, now and then, allowed
for. But the general character of the events stands out, resting on foundations
too broad to be shaken, and even details comparatively unimportant in themselves
are often remarkably corroborated from different quarters. The fact that
the Zeitounli exiles at Sultania were for some time prevented by the local
Turkish authorities from receiving relief is attested in Doc. 4 (Constantinople) and Doc. 123 (the town of B. in Cilicia),
as well as in Doc. 125 from Konia. The malicious trick by which the exiles from Shar were deflected from a
good road to a bad, in order that they might be compelled to abandon their
carts, is recorded independently in Docs. 12 and 126.
(v) In particular it is to be noted that many of the most shocking and horrible accounts are those for which there is the
most abundant testimony from the most trustworthy neutral witnesses. None of the worst cruelties rest on native evidence
alone. If all that class of evidence were entirely struck out, the general effect would be much the same, though some of the
minor details would be wanting. One may, indeed, say that an examination of the neutral evidence tends to confirm the native
evidence as a whole by showing that there is in it less of exaggeration than might have been expected.
Docs. 7 and 9, for instance, both of which are native reports at second-hand, refer in somewhat rhetorical
terms to the corpses of murdered Armenians washed down by the waters of the Tigris and Euphrates. Yet their words are more
than justified by many concrete and independent pieces of evidence. The description in Doc. 12 (German material) of
how barge-loads of Armenians were drowned in the Tigris below Diyarbekir, renders more fully credible the accounts of how
the Armenians of Trebizond were drowned wholesale in the Black Sea. Doc. 12 also contains the statement, from a German
employee of the Baghdad Railway, that the Armenian exiles who reached Biredjik were drowned in batches every night in the
Euphrates; and similar horrors are reported from almost every section of the Euphrates' course. Docs. 56, 57, 59 and 62
describe how the convoys of exiles from the Vilayet of Erzeroum were cast into the Kara Su (western branch of the Euphrates)
at the gorge called Kamakh Boghaz, and were then either shot in the water or left to drown. The author of Doc. 59
was present at such a scene, though she was herself spared, and the information in Docs. 56 and 57 was obtained direct
from a lady who was actually cast in, but managed to struggle to the bank and escape. The authors of Doc. 62 received
their information from a gendarme who had been attached to a convoy and had himself participated in the massacre. Doc. 24
records the experiences of an Armenian woman deported from Moush, who was driven with her fellow-exiles into the
Mourad Su (eastern branch of the Euphrates), but also managed to escape,
though the rest were drowned. Doc. 66 describes corpses floating in the river in the neighbourhood of Kiakhta, and Doc. 137
the drowning of exiles in the tributaries of the Euphrates between Harpout and Aleppo. These are evidently instances
of a regular practice, and when we find the exiles from Trebizond and Kerasond
being disposed of in the same fashion in a comparatively distant part of
the Turkish Empire, we are almost compelled to infer that the drowning of
the exiles en masse was a definite part of the general scheme drawn out by the Young Turk leaders at Constantinople.
Perhaps the most terrible feature of all was the suffering of the women with child, who were made to march with the
convoys and gave birth to their babies on the road. This is alluded to in Doc. 12, from a German source, at second-hand, but
in Docs. 129 and 137 we have the testimony of neutral witnesses who actually succoured these victims, so far as the extremity
of their plight and the brutality of their escort made succour possible. It should be mentioned that in Doc. 68 an Armenian
exile testifies to the kindness of an individual Turkish gendarme to one of her fellow-victims who was in these straits.
(vi) The vast scale of these massacres and the pitiless cruelty with which the deportations were carried out may seem to
some readers to throw doubt on the authenticity of the narratives. Can human beings (it may be asked) have perpetrated such
crimes on innocent women and children? But a recollection of previous massacres will show that such crimes are part of the
long settled and often repeated policy of Turkish rulers. In Chios, nearly a century ago, the Turks slaughtered almost the
whole Greek population of the island. In European Turkey in 1876 many thousands of Bulgarians were killed on the suspicion
of an intended rising, and the outrages committed on women were, on a smaller scale, as bad as those here recorded. In 1895
and 1896 more than a hundred thousand Armenian Christians were put to death by Abd-ul-Hamid, many thousands of whom died as
martyrs to their Christian faith, by abjuring which they could have saved their lives. All these massacres
are registered not only in the ordinary press records of current history
but in the reports of British diplomatic and consular officials written
at the time. They are as certain as anything else that has happened in our
day. There is, therefore, no antecedent improbability to be overcome before
the accounts here given can be accepted. All that happened in 1915 is in
the regular line of Turkish policy. The only differences are in the scale
of the present crimes, and in the fact that the lingering sufferings of
deportations in which the deaths were as numerous as in the massacres, and
fell with special severity upon the women, have in this latest instance been added.
The evidence is cumulative. Each part of it supports the rest because each part is independent of the others. The main facts are the same, and reveal the same plans and intentions at work. Even the varieties are instructive because they show those diversities of temper and feeling which appear in human nature everywhere.
The Turkish officials are usually heartless and callous. But here and there we see one of a finer temper, who refuses to carry out the orders given him and is sometimes dismissed for his refusal. The Moslem rabble is usually pitiless. It pillages the houses and robs the persons of the hapless exiles. But now and then there appear pious and compassionate Moslems who try to save the lives or alleviate the miseries of their Christian neighbours. We have a vivid picture of human life, where wickedness in high places deliberately lets loose the passions of racial or religious hatred, as well as the commoner passion of rapacity, yet cannot extinguish those better feelings which show as points of light in the gloom.
It is, however, for the reader to form his own judgment on these documents
as he peruses them. They do not, and by the nature of the case cannot, constitute
what is called judicial evidence, such as a Court of Justice obtains when
it puts witnesses on oath and subjects them to cross-examination. But by
far the larger part (almost all, indeed, of what is here published) does
constitute historical evidence of the best kind, inasmuch as the statements
come from those who saw the events they describe and recorded them in writing
immediately afterwards. They corroborate one another, the narratives given
by different observers showing a substantial agreement, which becomes conclusive
when we find the salient facts repeated with no more variations in detail
than the various opportunities of the independent observers made natural.
The gravest facts are those for which the evidence is most complete, and
it all tallies fatally with that which twenty years ago established the
guilt of Abd-ul-Hamid for the deeds that have made his name infamous. In
this case there are, moreover, what was wanting then, admissions which add
weight to the testimony here presented, I mean the admissions of the Turkish
Government and of their German apologists. The attempts made to find excuses for wholesale slaughter and for the removal
of a whole people from its homes leave no room for doubt as to the slaughter
and the removal. The main facts are established by the confession of the
criminals themselves. What the evidence here presented does is to show in
detail how these things were effected, what cruelties accompanied them,
and how inexcusable they were. The disproval of the palliations which the
Turks have put forward is as complete as the proof of the atrocities themselves.
In order to test the soundness of my own conclusions as to the value of the evidence, I have submitted it to the judgment of
three friends, men for whose opinion everyone who knows them will have the highest respect---a distinguished historian,
Mr. H. A. L. Fisher (Vice-Chancellor of the University of Sheffield); a distinguished scholar, Mr. Gilbert Murray (Professor
of Greek in the University of Oxford); and a distinguished American lawyer of long experience and high authority,
Mr. Moorfield Storey, of Boston, Mass.---men accustomed in their respective walks of life to examine and appraise evidence;
and I append the letters which convey their several views.
This preface is intended to deal only with the credibility of the evidence
here presented, so I will refrain from comment on the facts. A single observation,
or rather a single question, may, however, be permitted from one who has
closely followed the history of the Turkish East for more than forty years.
European travellers have often commended the honesty and the kindliness
of the Turkish peasantry, and our soldiers have said that they are fair
fighters. Against them I have nothing to say, and will even add that I have
known individual Turkish officials who impressed me as men of honesty and
good-will. But the record of the rulers of Turkey for the last two or three
centuries, from the Sultan on his throne down to the district Mutessarif,
is, taken as a whole, an almost unbroken record of corruption, of injustice,
of an oppression which often rises into hideous cruelty.
The Young Turks, when they deposed Abd-ul-Hamid, came forward as the apostles of freedom,
promising equal rights and equal treatment to all Ottoman subjects. The
facts here recorded show how that promise was kept. Can anyone still continue
to hope that the evils of such a government are curable? Or does the
evidence contained in this volume furnish the most terrible and convincing
proof that it can no longer be permitted to rule over subjects of a different faith?
BRYCE.
LETTER FROM MR. H. A. L. FISHER, VICE-CHANCELLOR OF SHEFFIELD UNIVERSITY, TO VISCOUNT BRYCE.
The University,
Sheffield, August 2nd, 1916.
MY DEAR LORD BRYCE,
The evidence here collected with respect to the sufferings of the Armenian
subjects of the Ottoman Empire during the present war will carry conviction
wherever and whenever it is studied by honest enquirers. It bears upon the
face of it all the marks of credibility. In the first place, the transactions
were recorded soon after they took place and while the memory of them was
still fresh and poignant. Then the greater part of the story rests upon
the word of eye-witnesses, and the remainder upon the evidence of persons
who had special opportunities for obtaining correct information. It is true
that some of the witnesses are Armenians, whose testimony, if otherwise
unconfirmed, might be regarded as liable to be over-coloured or distorted,
but the Armenian evidence does not stand alone. It is corroborated by reports
received from Americans, Danes, Swiss, Germans, Italians and other foreigners.
Again, this foreign testimony comes for the most part from men and women
whose calling alone entitles them to be heard with respect, that is to say,
from witnesses who may fairly be expected to exceed the average level of
character and intelligence and to view the transactions which they record
with as much, detachment as is compatible with human feeling. Indeed, the
foreign witnesses who happened to be spectators of the deportation, dispersion,
and massacre of the Armenian nation, do not strike me as being, in any one
case, blind and indiscriminate haters of the Turk. They are prompt to notice
facts which strike them as creditable to individual members of the Moslem
community.
I am also impressed with the cumulative effect of the evidence. Whoever
speaks, and from whatever quarter in the wide region covered by these reports
the voice may proceed, the story is one and the same. There are no discrepancies
or contradictions of importance, but, on the contrary, countless scattered
pieces of mutual corroboration. There is no contrariety as to the broad
fact that the Armenian population has been uprooted from its homes, dispersed,
and, to a large though not exactly calculable extent, exterminated in consequence
of general orders issued from Constantinople. It is clear that a catastrophe,
conceived upon a scale quite unparalleled in modern history, has been contrived
for the Armenian inhabitants of the Ottoman Empire. It is found that the
original responsibility rests with the Ottoman Government at Constantinople,
whose policy was actively seconded by the members of the Committee of Union
and Progress in the Provinces. And in view of the fact that the representations
of the Austrian Ambassador with the Porte were effectual in procuring a
partial measure of exemption for the Armenian Catholics, we are led to surmise
that the unspeakable horrors which this volume records might have been mitigated,
if not wholly checked, had active and energetic remonstrances been from
the first moment addressed to the Ottoman Government by the two Powers who
had acquired a predominant influence in Constantinople. The evidence, on
the contrary, tends to suggest that these two Powers were, in a general
way, favourable to the policy of deportation.
Yours sincerely,
HERBERT FISHER.
LETTER FROM PROFESSOR GILBERT MURRAY, REGIUS PROFESSOR OF GREEK IN THE UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD, TO VISCOUNT BRYCE.
82, Woodstock Road,
Oxford, June 27th, 1916.
DEAR LORD BRYCE,
I have spent some time studying the documents you are about to publish relative to the deportations and massacres of Armenians in the Turkish Empire during the spring and summer of 1915. I know, of course, how carefully a historian should scrutinize the evidence for events so startling in character, reported to have occurred in regions so far removed from the eyes of civilized Europe. I realize that in times of persecution passions run high, that oriental races tend to use hyperbolical language, and that the victims of oppression cannot be expected to speak with strict fairness of their oppressors. But the evidence of these letters and reports will bear any scrutiny and overpower any scepticism. Their genuineness is established beyond question, though obviously you are right in withholding certain of the names of persons and places. The statements of the Armenian refugees themselves are fully confirmed by residents of American, Scandinavian and even of German nationality; and the undesigned agreement between so many credible witnesses from widely separate districts puts all the main lines of the story beyond the possibility of doubt.
I remain,
Yours sincerely,
GILBERT MURRAY.
LETTER FROM MR. MOORFIELD STOREY, EX-PRESIDENT OF THE AMERICAN BAR ASSOCIATION, TO VISCOUNT BRYCE.
I have examined considerable portions of the volume which contains the statements regarding the treatment of the Armenians by the Turks, in order to determine the value of these statements as evidence.
I have no doubt that, while there may be inaccuracies of detail, these statements establish without any question the essential facts. It must be borne In mind that in such a case the evidence of eye-witnesses is not easily obtained; the victims, with few exceptions, are dead; the perpetrators will not confess; any casual spectators cannot be reached, and in most cases are either in sympathy with what was done or afraid to speak. There are no tribunals before which witnesses can be summoned and compelled to testify, and a rigid censorship is maintained by the authorities responsible for the crimes, which prevents the truth from coming out freely, and no investigation by impartial persons will be permitted.
Such statements as you print are the best evidence which, in the circumstances, it is possible to obtain. They come from persons holding positions which give weight to their words, and from other persons with no motive to falsify, and it is impossible that such a body of concurring evidence should have been manufactured. Moreover, it is confirmed by evidence from German sources which has with difficulty escaped the rigid censorship maintained by the German authorities---a censorship which is in itself a confession, since there is no reason why the Germans should not give full currency to such evidence unless the authorities felt themselves in some way responsible for what it discloses.
In my opinion, the evidence which you print is as reliable as that upon which rests our belief in many of the universally admitted facts of history, and I think it establishes beyond any reasonable doubt the deliberate purpose of the Turkish authorities practically to exterminate the Armenians, and their responsibility for the hideous atrocities which have been perpetrated upon that unhappy people.
Yours truly,
MOORFIELD STOREY.
LETTER, DATED ALEPPO, 8th OCTOBER, 1915, FROM FOUR MEMBERS OF THE GERMAN MISSIONS STAFF IN TURKEY TO THE IMPERIAL GERMAN MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS AT BERLIN.
We think it our duty to draw the attention of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs to the fact that our school work will be deprived, for the future, of its moral basis and will lose all authority in the eyes of the natives, if it is really beyond the power of the German Government to mitigate the brutality of the treatment which the exiled women and children of the massacred Armenians are receiving.
In face of the scenes of horror which are being unfolded daily before our eyes in the neighbourhood of our school, our educational activity becomes a mockery of humanity. How can we make our pupils listen to the Tales of the Seven Dwarfs, how can we teach them conjugations and declensions, when, in the compounds next door to our school, death is carrying off their starving compatriots---when there are girls and women and children, practically naked, some lying on the ground, others stretched between the dead or the coffins made ready for them beforehand, and breathing their last breath!
Out of 2,000 to 3,000 peasant women from the Armenian Plateau who were brought here in good health, only forty or fifty skeletons are left. The prettier ones are the victims of their gaolers' lust; the plain ones succumb to blows, hunger and thirst (they lie by the water's edge, but are not allowed to quench their thirst). The Europeans are forbidden to distribute bread to the starving. Every day more than a hundred corpses are carried out of Aleppo.
All this happens under the eyes of high Turkish officials. There are forty or fifty emaciated phantoms crowded into the compound opposite our school. They are women out of their mind; they have forgotten how to eat; when one offers them bread, they throw it aside with indifference. They only groan and wait for death.
" See," say the natives Taâlim el Alman (the teaching of the Germans)."
The German scutcheon is in danger of being smirched for ever in the memory of the Near Eastern peoples. There are natives of Aleppo, more enlightened than the rest, who say: "The Germans do not want these horrors. Perhaps the German nation does not know about them. If it did, how could the German Press, which is attached to the truth, talk about the humanity of the treatment accorded to the Armenians who are guilty of High Treason ? Perhaps, too, the German Government has its hands tied by some contract defining the powers of the [German and Turkish] State; in regard to one another's affairs ? "
No, when it is a question
of giving over thousands of women and children to death by starvation, the words "Opportunism" and "definition of powers" lose their meaning. Every civilised human being is "empowered" in this case to interfere, and it is his bounden duty to do so. Our prestige in the East is the thing at stake. There are even Turks and Arabs who have remained human, and who shake their heads in sorrow when they see, in the exile convoys that pass through the town, how the brutal soldiers shower blows on women with child who can march no farther.
We may expect further and still more dreadful hecatombs after the order published
by Djemal Pasha. (The engineers of the Baghdad Railway are forbidden, by this order, to photograph the Armenian convoys ; any plates they have already used for this must be given up within twenty-four hours, under penalty of prosecution before the Council of War.) It is a proof that the responsible authorities fear the light, but have no intention of putting an end to scenes which are a disgrace to humanity.
. . .We know that the Ministry of Foreign Affairs has already, from other sources, received detailed descriptions of. what is happening here. But as no change has occurred in the system of the deportations, we feel ourselves under a double obligation to make this report, all the more because the fact of our living abroad enables us to see more clearly the immense danger by which the German name is threatened here.
I. GENERAL DESCRIPTIONS
The Ottoman Government did its utmost to prevent the news
of what it was doing to the Armenians from leaking through to the outer
world. A stringent censorship was established at all the frontiers, private
communication was severed between Constantinople and the provinces, and
the provinces themselves were isolated from one another. Nearly all our
information has been obtained from witnesses who succeeded in making their
way out of Turkey after the massacres and deportations had occurred, and
who wrote down their experiences after reaching America or Europe. The evidence
of these witnesses is first-hand, but it is mostly confined to the particular
region in which each witness happened to reside, and it has therefore been
grouped in this collection province by province, in geographical order.
We possess, however, certain general accounts which reached Europe and America
at an earlier date, for the most part, than the individual narratives, and
they are printed here in advance of the rest---partly for the chronological
reason, and partly because they give a broad survey of what happened, which
may impress the general features upon the reader before he approaches the
detailed testimony of the sections that follow.
In contrast to the bulk of our evidence, the majority of these preliminary documents give their information at second-hand; but practically every statement they make is more than borne out in detail by the first-hand witnesses, and this is particularly the case with the more startling and appalling of the facts they record.
The most interesting document in this section is No. 12, which was compiled from German sources, published in a German journal, and immediately suppressed by the German Censorship.
1. DESPATCH FROM MR. HENRY WOOD, CORRESPONDENT OF THE AMERICAN "UNITED PRESS" AT CONSTANTINOPLE; PUBLISHED IN THE AMERICAN PRESS, 14th AUGUST, 1915.
So critical is the situation that Ambassador Morgenthau, who alone is
fighting to prevent wholesale slaughter, has felt obliged to ask the co-operation
of the Ambassadors of Turkey's two Allies. They have been successful to
the extent of securing definite promises from the leading members of the
Young Turk Government that no orders will be given for massacres. The critical
moment for the Armenians, however, will come, it is feared, when the Turks
may meet with serious reverses in the Dardanelles or when the Armenians
themselves, who not only are in open revolt but are actually in possession
of Van and several other important towns, may meet with fresh successes.
It is this uprising of the Armenians who are seeking to establish an independent
government that the Turks declare is alone responsible for the terrible
measures now being taken against them. In the meantime, the position of the Armenians and the system of deportation,
dispersion, and extermination that is being carried out against them beggars all description.
Although the present renewal of the Armenian atrocities has been under
way for three months, it is only just now that reports creeping into Constantinople
from the remotest points of the interior show that absolutely no portion
of the Armenian population has been spared. It now appears that the order
for the present cruelties was issued in the early part of May, and was at
once put into execution with all the extreme genius of the Turkish police
system---the one department of government for which the Turks have ever
shown the greatest aptitude, both in organisation and administration. At
that time sealed orders were sent to the police of the entire Empire. These
were to be opened on a specified date that would ensure the orders being
in the hands of every department at the moment they were to be opened. Once
opened, they provided for. a simultaneous descent at practically the same
moment on the Armenian population of the entire Empire.
At Broussa, in Asiatic Turkey, the city which it is expected the Turks
will select for their capital in the event of Constantinople falling, I
investigated personally the manner in which these orders were carried out. From eye-witnesses in other towns from the
interior I found that the execution of them was everywhere identical. At
midnight, the police authorities swooped down on the homes of all Armenians
whose names had been put on the proscribed list sent out from Constantinople.
The men were at once placed under arrest, and then the houses were searched
for papers which might implicate them either in the present revolutionary
movement of the Armenians on the frontier or In plots against the Government
which the Turks declare exist. In this search, carpets were torn from the
floors, draperies stripped from the walls, and even the children turned
out of their beds and cradles in order that the mattresses and coverings
might be searched.
Following this search, the men were then carried away, and at once there
began the carrying out of the system of deportation and dispersion which
has been the cruellest feature of the present anti-Armenian wave. The younger
men for the most part were at once drafted into the Army. On the authority
of men whose names would be known in both America and Europe if I dared
mention them, I am told that hundreds if not thousands of these were sent
at once to the front ranks at the Dardanelles, where death in a very short
space of time is almost a certainty. The older men were then deported into
the interior, while the women and children, when not carried off in an opposite
direction, were left to shift for themselves as best they could. The terrible
feature of this deportation up to date is that it has been carried out on
such a basis as to render it practically impossible in thousands of cases
that these families can ever again be reunited. Not only wives and husbands,
brothers and sisters, but even mothers and their little children have been
dispersed in such a manner as to preclude practically all I hope that they
will ever see each other again.
In defence of these terrible measures which have been taken, the Turks
at Constantinople declare that no one but the Armenians themselves is to
blame. They state that when the present attack began on the Dardanelles,
the Armenians were, notified that if they took advantage of the moment when
the Turks were concentrating every energy for the maintenance of the Empire,
to rise in rebellion, they would be dealt with without quarter. This warning,
however, the Armenians failed to heed. They not only rose in rebellion,
occupying a number of important towns, including Van, but extended important
help to the Russians in the latter's campaign in the Caucasus.
While this is the Turkish side of the situation, there is also another
side which I shall give on the authority of men who have passed practically
their entire lives in Turkey and whose names, if I dared mention them, would
be recognised in both Europe and America as competent authority. According
to these men, the decision has gone out from the Young Turk party that the
Armenian population of Turkey must be set back fifty years. This has been
decided upon as necessary in order to ensure the supremacy of the Turkish
race in the Ottoman Empire, which is one of the basic principles of the
Young Turk party. The situation, I am told, is absolutely analogous to that
which preceded the Armenian massacres under Abd-ul-Hamid. So far, however,
the Young Turks have confined themselves to the new system of deportation,
dispersion and separation of families.
....
4. LETTER FROM AN AUTHORITATIVE SOURCE, DATED CONSTANTINOPLE, 15th / 28th JUNE, 1915; PUBLISHED IN THE NEW YORK JOURNAL "GOTCHNAG," 28th AUGUST, 1915.
In America you have probably not yet heard of the terrible crisis through
which the Armenians of Turkey are passing at this moment. The severe censorship
to which all communications between Constantinople and the provinces are
subjected, and the absolute embargo on travelling under which the Armenians
have been placed, have resulted in depriving us, even in Constantinople,
of all but the scantiest information regarding the whole provincial area.
And yet what we know already is sufficient to give you some idea.
In every part of Turkey the Armenian population is in a more or less
serious plight, in suspense between life and death. Apart from the distress
produced by the illegal requisitions, the paralysis of industry, the ravages
of the typhus, and the mobilisation of the men---first of those from 20
to 45, and then of those from 18 to 50 years of age---thousands of Armenians
have been suffering during the last two months in prison or in exile.
At the beginning of the month of April, immediately after the events
at Van, the Government issued an order requisitioning Armenian houses, schools,
and episcopal residences, even in the most obscure corners of the provinces,
and making the possession of arms, which were allowed until now, or of books
and images, which were freely sold in public, a pretext for imprisonments
and convictions. The effect of this order has beep such that in the prisons
of Kaisaria alone there are, at the present moment, more than 500 Armenians
in custody, without reckoning those who, by a mere administrative act and
without any charge being brought against them, have been deported into districts inhabited entirely by Mohammedans.
However, even this state of things is mild enough in comparison with the condition of affairs in Cilicia and the provinces bordering on the Caucasus.
The Turkish Government is now putting into execution its plan of dispersing
the Armenian population of the Armenian provinces, taking advantage of the
preoccupation of all the European Powers, and of the indifference of Germany
and Austria. They began to execute this plan about four months ago, starting
with Cilicia, where the entire Armenian population of Zeitoun, Dört Yöl and the neighbourhood, and a considerable
part of the population of Marash and Hassan-Beyli, have been removed from their homes by brute force and without warning.
Some of the exiles, about 1,000 families,: have been sent to the Sultania
district of the Vilayet of Konia. The majority,
however, have been dispersed among the villages of the province of Zor,
beyond Aleppo, and through the districts in the immediate neighbourhood
of Aleppo itself---Moumbidj, Bab, Ma'ara, Idlib, etc. This compulsory emigration
is still in progress. The same fate is in prospect for Adana, Mersina, Hadjin,
Sis, etc. As can be seen from the despatches and letters which arrive from
these districts, all these people are being deported without the possibility
of taking anything with them, and this into districts with a climate to
which they are absolutely unaccustomed. There, without shelter, naked and
famished, they are abandoned to their fate, and have to subsist on the morsel
of bread which the Government sees good to throw to them, a Government which
is incapable of providing even its own troops with bread.
The least details of this compulsory emigration that reach us at Constantinople, reduce one to tears at their recital. Among those 1,000 families deported to Sultania there are less than fifty men. The majority made the journey on foot ; the old people and the young children died by the wayside, and young women with child miscarried and were abandoned on the mountains. Even now that they have reached their place of exile, these deported Armenians pay a toll of about ten victims a day in deaths from sickness and famine. At Aleppo they need at present £35 (Turkish) a day to provide the exiles with bread. You can imagine what their situation must be in the deserts, where the native Arabs themselves are near starvation.
A sum of money has been sent from Constantinople to the Katholikos of Cilicia, who is at the present moment at Aleppo, witnessing the misery and agony of his flock. At Aleppo, at any rate, the authorities permit the distribution of relief to these unfortunate people ; at Sultania, on the other hand, it has so far been impossible to bring any relief within their reach, because the Government refuses permission, in spite of the efforts of the American Embassy.
The same state of affairs now prevails at Erzeroum, Bitlis, Sairt, etc. According to absolutely trustworthy information which we have received, they have begun, during the last two or three weeks, to deport the Armenians of Erzeroum. and the neighbourhood towards Derdjan; the rest have been given several days' grace. From Bitlis and Sairt we have just had despatches forwarded to us, imploring relief. From Moush we have no news, but the same state of affairs must certainly prevail there also. At Klinyss there has been a massacre, but we do not yet know how serious it was. In the neighbourhood of Sivas several villages, Govdoun among others, have been burnt. . . .
5. LETTER FROM THE SAME SOURCE, DATED CONSTANTINOPLE, 12 /25th JULY, 1915; PUBLISHED IN THE NEW YORK JOURNAL "GOTCHNAG," 28th AUGUST, 1915.
Since my last letter, our nation's position has unhappily become more serious, inasmuch as it is now not merely the Armenians of Cilicia who have been deported, but the Armenians of all the native Armenian provinces. From Samsoun and Kaisaria on the one hand to Edessa on the other, about a million and a half people are at this moment on their way to the deserts of Mesopotamia, to be planted in the midst of Arab and Kurdish populations. These people cannot take with them anything but the barest necessities, because of the impossibility of transport and the insecurity of the roads; so that very few of them indeed will succeed in reaching the spot marked out for their exile, while, if immediate relief is not sent them, they will die of hunger. . . .
6. LETTER FROM THE SAME SOURCE, DATED CONSTANTINOPLE, 13 /26th JULY, 1915, AND ADDRESSED TO A DISTINGUISHED ARMENIAN RESIDENT BEYOND THE OTTOMAN FRONTIER.
Since the 25th May last, events have followed hard upon one another, and the misery of our nation is now at its zenith.
Apart from a few rumours about the situation of the Armenians at Erzeroum, we had heard of nothing, till recently, except the deportation of the inhabitants of several towns and villages in Cilicia. Now we know from an unimpeachable source that the Armenians of all the towns and all the villages of Cilicia have been deported en masse to the desert regions south of Aleppo.
From the 1st May onwards, the population of the city of Erzeroum, and
shortly afterwards the population of the whole province, was collected at
Samsoun and embarked on shipboard. The populations of Kaisaria, Diyarbekir,
Ourfa, Trebizond, Sivas, Harpout and the district of Van have been deported
to the deserts of Mesopotamia, from the southern outskirts of Aleppo as
far as Mosul and Baghdad. "Armenia without the Armenians"---that
is the Ottoman Government's project. The Moslems are already being allowed
to take possession of the lands and houses abandoned by the Armenians.
The exiles are forbidden to take anything with them. For that matter,
in the districts under military occupation there is nothing left to take,
as the military authorities have exerted themselves to carry off, for their
own use, everything that they could lay hands on.
The exiles will have to traverse on foot a distance that involves one
or two months' marching and sometimes even more, before they reach the particular
corner of the desert assigned to them for their habitation, and destined
to become their tomb. We hear, in fact, that the course of their route and
the stream of the Euphrates are littered with the corpses of exiles, while
those who survive are doomed to certain death, since they will find in the
desert neither house, nor work, nor food.
It is simply a scheme for exterminating the Armenian nation wholesale, without any fuss. It is just another form of massacre, and a more horrible form.
Remember that all the men between the ages of 20 and 45 are at the front.
Those between 45 and 60 are working for the military transport service.
As for those who had paid the statutory tax for exemption from military
service, they have either been exiled or imprisoned on one pretext or another.
The result is that there is no one left to deport but the old men, the women
and the children. These poor creatures have to travel through regions which,
even in times of peace, were reputed dangerous, and where there was a serious
risk of being robbed. Now that the Turkish brigands, as well as the gendarmes
and civil officials, enjoy the most absolute licence, the exiles will inevitably
be robbed on the road, and their women and girls dishonoured and abducted.
We are hearing also from various places of conversions to Islam. It seems that the people have no other alternative for saving their lives.
The courts martial are working everywhere at full pressure.
You must have heard through the newspapers of the hanging of 20 Huntchakists
at Constantinople. The verdict given against them is not based on any of
the established laws of the Empire. The same day twelve Armenians were hanged
at Kaisaria, on the charge of having obeyed instructions received from the
secret conference held at Bukarest by the Runtchakists and Droshakists.
Besides these hangings, 32 persons have been sentenced at Kaisaria to terms
of hard labour, ranging from ten to fifteen years. Most of them are honest
merchants who are in no sort of relation with the political parties. Twelve
Armenians have also been hanged in Cilicia. Condemnations have become daily
occurrences. The discovery of arms, books and pictures is enough to condemn
an Armenian to several years' imprisonment.
Besides this many people have succumbed under the rod. Thirteen Armenians
have been killed in this way at Diyarbekir, and six at Kaisaria. Thirteen
others have been killed on their way to Shabin Kara-Hissar and Sivas. The
priests of the village of Kourk with their companions have suffered the
same fate on the road between Sou-Shehr and Sivas, although they had their
hands pinioned and were defenceless.
I will spare you the recital of other outrages which have occurred sporadically all over the country, under the cloak of searches for arms and for revolutionary agents. Not a single house has been left unsearched, not even the episcopal
residences, the churches or the schools. Hundreds of women, girls, and even
quite young children are groaning in prison. Churches and convents have
been pillaged, desecrated and destroyed. Even the Bishops are not spared.
Mgr. Barkev Danielian (Bishop of Broussa), Mgr. Kevork Tourian (Bishop of
Trebizond), Mgr. Khosrov Behrikian (Bishop of Kaisaria), Mgr. Vaghinadj
Torikian (Bishop of Shabin Kara-Hissar), and Mgr. Kevork Nalbandian (Bishop
of Tchar-Sandjak) have been arrested and handed over to the courts martial.
Father Muggerditch, locum-tenens of the Bishop of Diyarbekir, has died of
blows received in prison. We have no news of the other bishops, but I imagine
that the greater part of them are in prison.
We are so cut off from the world that we might be in a fortress. We have no means of correspondence, neither post nor telegraph.
The villages in the neighbourhood of Van and Bitlis have been plundered,
and their inhabitants put to the sword. At the beginning of this month,
there was a pitiless massacre of all the inhabitants of Kara-Hissar with
the exception of a few children who are said to have escaped by a miracle.
Unhappily we learn the details of all these occurrences too late, and even
then only with the utmost difficulty.
So you see that the Armenians in Turkey have only a few more days to live, and if the Armenians abroad do not succeed in enlisting the sympathy of the neutrals on our behalf, there will be extraordinarily few Armenians left a few months hence, out of the million and a half that there were in Turkey before the war. The annihilation of the Armenian nation will then be inevitable.
7. LETTER FROM THE SAME SOURCE, DATED CONSTANTINOPLE, 2 /15th AUGUST, 1915, AND ADDRESSED TO THE SAME ARMENIAN RESIDENT BEYOND THE OTTOMAN FRONTIER.
Since I wrote my last letter (of which you have acknowledged the receipt),
we have been able to obtain more precise information from the provinces
of the interior. The information with which we present you herewith is derived
from the following witnesses : an Armenian lady forcibly converted
to Islam, and brought by an unforeseen chance to Constantinople ; a
girl from Zila, between nine and ten years old, who was abducted by a Turkish
officer and has reached Constantinople; a Turkish traveller from Harpout;
foreign travellers from Erzindjan, and so on. In fine, this information
is derived either from eye-witnesses or from actual victims of the crimes.
It is now established that there is not an Armenian left in the provinces
of Erzeroum, Trebizond, Sivas, Harpout, Bitlis and Diyarbekir. About a million
of the Armenian inhabitants of these provinces have been deported from their
homes and sent southwards into exile. These deportations have been carried
out very systematically by the local authorities since the beginning of
April last. First of all, in every village and every town, the population
was disarmed by the gendarmerie, and by criminals released for this purpose
from prison. On the pretext of disarming the Armenians, these criminals
committed assassinations and inflicted hideous tortures. Next, they imprisoned
the Armenians en masse, on the pretext that they had found in their
possession arms, books, a political organisation, and so on---at a pinch,
wealth or any kind of social standing was pretext enough. After that, they
began the deportation. And first, on the pretext of sending them into exile,
they evicted such men as had not been imprisoned, or such as had been set
at liberty through lack of any charge against them ; then they massacred
them---not one of these escaped slaughter. Before they started, they were
examined officially by the authorities, and any money or valuables in their
possession were confiscated. They were usually shackled--either separately,
or in gangs of five to ten. The remainder---old men, women, and children---were
treated as waifs in the province of Harpout, and placed at the disposal
of the Moslem population. The highest official, as well as the most simple
peasant, chose out the woman or girl who caught his fancy, and took her
to wife, converting her by force to Islam. As for the children, the Moslems
took as many of them as they wanted, and then the remnant of the Armenians
were marched away, famished and destitute of provisions, to fall victims
to hunger, unless that were anticipated by the savagery of the brigand-bands.
In the province of Diyarbekir there was an outright massacre, especially
at Mardin, and the population was subjected to all the afore-mentioned atrocities.
In the provinces of Erzeroum, Bitlis, Sivas and Diyarbekir, the local
authorities gave certain facilities to the Armenians condemned to deportation;
five to ten days' grace, authorisation to effect a partial sale of their
goods, and permission to hire a cart, in the case of some families. But
after the first few days of their journey, the carters abandoned them on
the road and returned home. These convoys were waylaid the day after the
start, or sometimes several days after, by bands of brigands or by Moslem
peasants who spoiled them of all they had. The brigands fraternised with
the gendarmes and slaughtered the few grown men or youths who were included
in the convoys. They carried off the women, girls and children, leaving
only the old women, who were driven along by the gendarmes under blows of
the lash and died of hunger by the roadside. An eye-witness reports to us
that the women deported from the province of Erzeroum were abandoned, some
days ago, on the plain of Harpout, where they have all died of hunger (50 or 60 a day).
The only step taken by the authorities was to send people to bury them, In order to safeguard the health of the Moslem population.
The little girl from Zila tells us that when the Armenians of Marsovan,
Amasia and Tokat reached Sari-Kishila (between Kaisaria and Sivas), the
children of both sexes were torn from their mothers before the very windows
of the Government Building, and were locked up in certain other buildings,
while the convoy was forced to continue its march. After that, they gave
notice in the neighbouring villages that anyone might come and take his
choice. She and her companion (Newart of Amasia) were carried off and brought
to Constantinople by a Turkish officer. The convoys of women and children
were placed on view in front of the Government Building at each town or
village where they passed, to give the Moslems an opportunity of taking their choice.
The convoy which started from Baibourt was thinned out in this way, and
the women and children who survived were thrown into the Euphrates on the
outskirts of Erzindjan, at a place called Kamakh-Boghazi. Mademoiselle Flora A. Wedel Yarlesberg, a Norwegian lady of good family
who was a nurse in a German Red Cross hospital, and another nurse who was
her colleague, were so revolted by these barbarities and by other experiences
of equal horror, that they tendered their resignations, returned to Constantinople,
and called personally at several Embassies to denounce these hideous crimes.
The same barbarities have been committed everywhere, and by this time
travellers find nothing but thousands of Armenian corpses along all the
roads in these provinces. A Moslem traveller on his way from Malatia to
Sivas, a nine hours' journey, passed nothing but corpses of men and women.
All the male Armenians of Malatia had been taken there and massacred; the
women and children have all been converted to Islam. No Armenian can travel
in these parts, for every Moslem, and especially the brigands and gendarmes,
considers it his duty now to kill them at sight. Recently Messieurs Zohrad
and Vartkes, two Armenian members of the Ottoman Parliament, who had been
sent off to Diyarbekir to be tried by the Council of War, were killed, before
they got there, at a short distance from Aleppo. In these provinces one
can only travel incognito under a Moslem name. As for the women's
fate, we have already spoken of it above, and it seems unnecessary to go
into further particulars about their honour, when one sees the utter disregard
there is for their life.
The Armenian soldiers, too, have suffered the same fate. They were also all disarmed and put to constructing roads. We have certain knowledge that the Armenian soldiers of the province of Erzeroum, who were at work on the road from Erzeroum to Erzindjan, have all been massacred. The Armenian soldiers of the province of Diyarbekir have all been massacred on the Diyarbekir-Ourfa road, and the Diyarbekir-Harpout road. From Harpout alone, 1,800 young Armenians were enrolled and sent off to work at Diyarbekir ; all were massacred in the neighbourhood of Arghana. We have no news from the other districts, but they have assuredly suffered the same fate there also.
In certain towns, the Armenians who had been consigned to oblivion in
the prisons have been hanged in batches. During the past month alone, several
dozen Armenians have been hanged in Kaisaria. In many places the Armenian
inhabitants, to save their lives, have tried to become Mohammedans, but
this time such overtures have not been readily accepted, as they were at
the time of the other great massacres. At Sivas, the would-be converts to
Islam were offered the following terms : they must hand over all children
under twelve years of age to the Government, which would undertake to place
them in orphanages; and they must consent, for their own part, to leave
their homes and settle wherever the Government directed.
At Harpout, they would not accept the conversion of the men; in the case of the women, they made their conversion conditional in each instance upon the presence of a Moslem willing to take the convert in marriage. Many Armenian women preferred to throw themselves into the Euphrates with their infants, or committed suicide in their homes. The Euphrates and Tigris have become the sepulchre of thousands of Armenians.
All Armenians converted in the Black Sea towns---Trebizond, Samsoun,
Kerasond, etc.---have been sent to the interior, and settled in towns inhabited
exclusively by Moslems. The town of Shabin-Karahissar resisted the disarming
and deportation, and was thereupon bombarded. The whole population of the
town and the surrounding country, from the Bishop downwards, was pitilessly massacred.
In short, from Samsoun on the one hand to Seghert and Diyarbekir on the other, there is now not a single Armenian left. The majority have been massacred, part have been carried off, and a very small part have been converted to Islam.
History has never recorded, never hinted at, such a hecatomb. We are driven to believe that under the reign of Sultan Abd-ul-Hamid we were exceedingly fortunate.
We have just learned the fate of some of the provincial bishops. Mgr.
Anania Hazarabedian, Bishop of Baibourt, has been hanged without any confirmation
of the sentence by the Central Government.
Mgr. Bosak Der-Khoremian. Bishop of Harpout, started on his road to exile
in May, and had barely left the outskirts of the town when he was cruelly
murdered. But we have still, no news of the Bishops of Segliert, Bitlis,
Moush, Keghi, Palou, Erzindjan, Kamakh, Tokat, Gurin, Samsoun and Trebizond,
or for a month past of the Bishops of Sivas and Erzeroum. It is superfluous
to speak of the martyred priests. When the people were deported, the churches
were pillaged and turned into mosques, stables, or what not. Besides that,
they have begun to sell at Constantinople the sacred objects and other properties
of the Armenian churches, just as the Turks have begun to bring to Constantinople
the children of the unhappy Armenian mothers.
It appears that the massacres have been less cruel in Cilicia, or at
least we have no news yet of the worst. The population, which has been deported
to the provinces of Aleppo and Der-el-Zor and to Damascus, will certainly
perish of hunger. We have just heard that the Government has refused to
leave in peace even the insignificant Armenian colonies at Aleppo and Ourfa,
who might have assisted their unhappy brethren on their southward road;
and the Katholikos of Cilicia, who still remains at Aleppo, is busy distributing
the relief we are forwarding to him.
We thought at first that the Government's plan was to settle the Armenian
question once and for all by clearing out the Armenians of the six Armenian
provinces and removing the Armenian population of Cilicia, to forestall
another danger in the future. Unhappily their plan was wider in scope and
more thorough in intention. It consisted in the extermination of the whole
Armenian population throughout the whole of Turkey. The result is that,
in those seven provinces where the Government was pledged to introduce reforms,
there is not one per cent. of the Armenian population left alive. So far,
we do not know whether a single Armenian has reached Mosul or its neighbourhood.
And this plan has now been put into execution even in the suburbs of Constantinople.
The majority of the Armenians in the district of Ismid and in the province
of Broussa have been forcibly deported to Mesopotamia, leaving behind them
their homes and their property. In detail, the population of Adapazar, Ismid,
Gegvé, Armasha and the neighbourhood has been removed---in fact,
the population of all the villages in the Ismid district (except Baghtchedjik,
which has been granted several days' grace). The Principal of the Seminary
at Armasha has also been removed with his colleagues in orders and his seminarists. They have had to leave everything behind, and
been able to take nothing with them on their journey. Six weeping mothers
confided their little ones to the Armenians of Konia, in order to save their
lives, but the local authorities tore them away from their Armenian guardians,
and handed them over to Moslems.
So now it is Constantinople's turn. In any case, the population has fallen
into a panic, and is waiting from one moment to another for the execution
of its doom. The arrests are innumerable, and those arrested are immediately
removed from the capital. The majority will assuredly perish. It is the
retail merchants of provincial birth, but resident in Constantinople, who
are so far being deported---among them Marouké, Ipranossian Garabed,
Kherbekian of Erzeroum, Atamian Karekin, Krikorian Sempad of Bitlis, etc.
We are making great efforts to save at any rate the Armenians of Constantinople
from this horrible extermination of the race, in order that, hereafter,
we may have at least one rallying point for the Armenian cause in Turkey.
Is there anything further to add to this report? The whole Armenian population of Turkey has been condemned to death, and this decree is being put into execution energetically in every corner of the Empire, under the eyes of the European Powers; while, so far, neither Germany nor Austria has succeeded in checking the action of their ally and removing the stain of these barbarities, which also attaches to them. All our efforts have been without result. Our hope is set upon the Armenians abroad.
.....
11. MEMORANDUM DATED 15/28th OCTOBER, 1915, FROM A WELL-INFORMED SOURCE AT BUKAREST, RELATING TO THE EXTERMINATION OF THE ARMENIANS IN TURKEY.
1. At Vezir Köprü (district of Marsovan) all Armenian women and girls from 7 to 40 years of age have been sold at auction. Women were also presented to the buyers without payment.
2. At Kaisaria more than 500 Armenian families were forced to embrace Islam. A father asked his son in Constantinople to follow his example, "in order to prevent worse consequences for his parents."
3. All Armenian judicial officials in the provinces have been discharged. All Turkish officials who have shown special zeal in the extermination of the Armenians have been promoted. Thus Zeki Bey, Kaimakam of Develou (Kaisaria), the man who directed in person the terrible tortures of the Armenian prisoners and was responsible for the death of most of them, has been made mektoubdji of the Vilayet of Constantinople.
4. The Young Turk Government has published, as an excuse or perhaps as a means of exciting greater hatred against the Armenians, a book entitled The Armenian Separatist Movement, which is as ridiculous as it is criminal. The reader finds in it not only copies of entirely fictitious publications, but actually pictures of enormous depots of arms and munitions purporting to be Armenian.
5. In Konia, and everywhere else, the wives of the Armenian soldiers who have not been deported have been taken as servants or concubines into Turkish families.
6. In Marash more than three hundred Armenians have been executed
by Court Martial, besides the numerous victims murdered in the course of
the deportations. At Panderma many important Armenians have been
condemned to death by the Court Martial. The vicar Barkev Vartabed has been
condemned to five years' penal servitude. The Archbishop of Erzeroum, His
Grace Sempad, who, with the Vali's authorisation, was returning to Constantinople,
was murdered at Erzindjan by the brigands in the service of the Union and
Progress Committee. The bishops of Trebizond, Kaisaria, Moush, Bitlis, Sairt,
and Erzindjan have all been murdered by order of the Young Turk Government.
According to reports from travellers, all the Armenian population of Trebizond
has been massacred without exception. Almost the whole male population in
Sivas, Erzeroum, Harpout, Bitlis, Baibourt, Khnyss, Diyarbekir, etc., has
been exterminated. At Tchingiler, a small village in the district of Ismid,
300 men have been murdered because they did not obey the order to leave
their houses. The people deported from Rodosto, Malgara and Tehorlu, who
have been deprived of all their possessions in accordance with the new "temporary
law" of the 13/26th September, have been separated from their families
and sent on foot from Ismid to Konia on the arbitrary order of the notorious
Ibrahim, dictator of the Ismid district. Thousands of poor Armenians expelled
from Constantinople are made to march on foot from Ismid to Konia and still
further, after they have delivered up everything they possess to the gendarmes,
including their shoes. Those who can afford to travel by rail are also fleeced
by the gendarmes, who not only demand the price of the ticket from Constantinople
to their destinations, but extract the whole of their money by selling them
food at exorbitant prices. They demand payment even for unlocking the door
of the water-closet.
7. German travellers from Aleppo describe the misery of the deported Armenians as terrible. All along the route they saw corpses of Armenians who had died of hunger.
The Arab deputies from Bagdad and Syria report that the misery in the deserts of Hauran is indescribable :
"The railway discharges into the mountains vast numbers of Armenians,
who are abandoned there without bread or water. In the towns and villages,
the Arabs try to bring them some relief; but generally the Armenians are
abandoned at five or six hours' distance from their homes. We saw on the
way numbers of women and old men and children dying of hunger, who did not
know where to look for help."
Some Armenians are leading a life of misery among the Arabs, forty or forty-five hours' journey from Bagdad. Every day numbers of them die of hunger. The Government gives them no food. Moreover, fresh troops have been sent to Bagdad, and these will be a new scourge to the unfortunate exiles.
8. Three Special Commissions have been sent through the provinces to liquidate the abandoned goods and estates of the Armenians, in conformity with the new temporary law" of the 13/26th September, 1915.
12. INFORMATION REGARDING EVENTS IN ARMENIA, PUBLISHED IN THE "SONNENAUFGANG" (ORGAN OF THE "GERMAN LEAGUE FOR THE PROMOTION OF CHRISTIAN CHARITABLE WORK IN THE EAST "), OCTOBER, 1915; AND IN THE "ALLGEMEINE MISSIONS-ZEITSCHRIFT." NOVEMBER, 1915.
This testimony is especially significant because it comes from a German source, and because the German Censor made a strenuous attempt to suppress it.
The same issue of the "Sonnenaufgang" contains the following editorial note :
"In our preceding issue we published an account by one of our sisters (Schwester Möhring) of her experiences on a journey, but we have to abstain from giving to the public the new details that are reaching us in abundance. It costs us much to do so, as our friends will understand ; but the political situation of our country demands it."
In the case of the "Allgemeine Missions-Zeitschrift," the Censor was not content with putting pressure on the editor. On the 10th November, he forbade the reproduction of the present article in the German press, and did his best to confiscate the whole current issue of the magazine. Copies of both publications, however, found their way across the frontier.
Both the incriminating articles are drawn from common sources, but the extracts they make from them do not entirely coincide, so that, by putting them together, a fuller version of these sources can be compiled.
In the text printed below, the unbracketed paragraphs are those which appear both in the "Sonnenaufgang" and in the "Allgemeine Missions-Zeitschrift" ; while paragraphs included in angular brackets (< >) appear only in the "Sonnenaufgang," and those in square brackets ([ ]) only in the " Allgemeine Missions-Zeitschrift."
Between the loth and the 30th May, 1,200 of the most prominent Armenians and other Christians, without distinction of confession, were arrested in the Vilayets of Diyarbekir and Mamouret-ul-Aziz.
<It is said that they were to be taken to Mosul, but nothing more has been heard of them.>
[On the 30th May, 674 of them were embarked on thirteen Tigris barges, under the pretext that they were to be taken to Mosul. The Vali's aide-de-camp, assisted by fifty gendarmes, was in charge of the convoy. Half the gendarmes started off on the barges, while the other half rode along the bank. A short time after the start the prisoners were stripped of all their money (about £6,000 Turkish) and then of their clothes ; after that they were thrown into the river. The gendarmes on the bank were ordered to let none of them escape. The clothes of these victims were sold in the market of Diyarbekir.]
<About the same time 700 young Armenian men were conscribed, and were then set to build the Karabaghtché-Habashi road. There is no news of these 700 men either.
It is said that in Diyarbekir five or six priests were stripped naked one day, smeared with tar, and dragged through the streets.>
In the Vilayet of Aleppo they have evicted the inhabitants of Hadjin, Shar, Albustan, Göksoun, Tasholouk, Zeitoun, all the villages of Alabash, Geben, Shivilgi, Furnus and the surrounding villages, Fundadjak, Hassan-Beyli, Harni, Lappashli, Dört Yöl and others.
[They have marched them off in convoys into the desert on the pretext of settling them there. In the village of Tel-Armen (along the line of the Bagdad Railway, near Mosul) and in the neighbouring villages about 5,000 people were massacred, leaving only a few women and children. The people were thrown alive down wells or into the fire. They pretend that the Armenians are to be employed in colonising land situated at a distance of from twenty-four to thirty kilometres from the Bagdad Railway. But as it is only the women and children who are sent into exile, since all the men, with the exception of the very old, are at the war, this means nothing less than the wholesale murder of the families, since they have neither the labour nor the capital for clearing the country.]
A German met a Christian soldier of his acquaintance, who was on furlough from Jerusalem. The man was wandering up and down along the banks of the Euphrates searching for his wife and children, who were supposed to have been transferred to that neighbourhood. Such unfortunates are often to be met with in Aleppo, because they believe that there they will learn something more definite about the whereabouts of their relations. It has often happened that when a member of a family has been absent, he discovers on his return that all his family are gone---evicted from their homes.
[For a whole month corpses were observed floating down the River Euphrates nearly every day, often in batches of from two to six corpses bound together. The male corpses are in many cases hideously mutilated (sexual organs cut off, and so on), the female corpses are ripped open. The Turkish military authority in control of the Euphrates, the Kaimakam of Djerablous, refuses to allow the burial of these corpses, on the ground that he finds it impossible to establish whether they belong to Moslems or to Christians. He adds that no one has given him any orders on the subject. The corpses stranded on the bank are devoured by dogs and vultures. To this fact there are many German eyewitnesses. An employee of the Bagdad Railway has brought the information that the prisons at Biredjik are filled regularly every day and emptied every night---into the Euphrates. Between Diyarbekir and Ourfa a German cavalry captain saw innumerable corpses lying unburied all along the road.]
<The following telegram was sent to Aleppo from Arabkir:---"We have accepted the True Religion. Now we are all right." The inhabitants of a village near Anderoum went over to Islam and had to hold to it. At Hadjin six families wanted to become Mohammedans. They received the verdict: "Nothing under one hundred families will be accepted."
Aleppo and Ourfa are the assemblage-places for the convoys of exiles.
There were about 5,000 of them in Aleppo during June and July, while during
the whole period from April to July many more than 50,000 must have passed
through the city. The girls were abducted almost without exception by the
soldiers and their Arab hangers-on. One father, on the verge of despair,
besought me to take with me at least his fifteen-year-old daughter, as he
could no longer protect her from the persecutions inflicted upon her. The
children left behind by the Armenians on their journey are past counting.
Women whose pains came upon them on the way had to continue their journey
without respite. A woman bore twins in the neighbourhood of Aintab; next
morning she had to go on again. She very soon had to leave the children
under a bush, and a little while after she collapsed herself. Another, whose
pains came upon her during the march, was compelled to go on at once and
fell down dead almost immediately. There were several more incidents of
the same kind between Marash and Aleppo.
The villagers of Shar were permitted to carry all their household effects
with them. On the road they were suddenly told: "An order has come
for us to leave the high road and travel across the mountains." Everything---waggons,
oxen and belongings---had to be left behind on the road, and then they went
on over the mountains on foot. This year the heat has been exceptionally
severe, and many women and children naturally succumbed to it even in these
early stages of their journey.
There are about 30,000 exiles of whom we have no news at all, as they have arrived neither at Aleppo nor at Ourfa.>
.....
II.
VILAYET OF VAN.
The Vilayet of Van had a higher percentage of Armenians
in its population than any other province of the Ottoman Empire; it
was also the border province of the north-eastern frontier, towards Russian
and Persian territory, and as such was the earliest to be exposed to invasion
after the breakdown of the Turkish offensive against the Caucasus in the
winter of 1914-1915.
The documents contained in this section give a detailed
and perfectly self-consistent account, from five independent sources, of
those events at Van which led to the first open breach between the Armenians
in the Ottoman Empire and the Turks, and which gave the Government a pretext
for extending the scheme of deportation already operative in Cilicia to
the whole Armenian population under its jurisdiction.
The evidence makes it clear that there was no unprovoked insurrection of the Armenians at Van, as the Ottoman Government asserts in its official apologia. The Armenians only took up arms in self-defence, and the entire responsibility for the outbreak rests with Djevdet Bey, the local governor-whether he was acting on his own initiative or was simply carrying out instructions from Constantinople.
15. THE AMERICAN MISSION AT VAN: NARRATIVE PRINTED PRIVATELY IN THE UNITED STATES BY MISS GRACE HIGLEY KNAPP (1915).
The first part of this narrative, down to and including the subsection headed "Deliverance," has been transcribed almost word for word by Miss Knapp from a letter she wrote at Van, on the 24th May, 1915, to Dr. Barton, and has, therefore, all the value of contemporary evidence.
The period of the (first) Russian occupation of Van is also covered by two further letters from Miss Knapp to Dr. Barton---a long one written piece-meal on the 14th, 20th and 22nd June, and a second dated 26th July. These contain much more detail than the three corresponding sub-sections of her narrative, but the detail is principally devoted to personal matters and to the care of the Moslem refugees. As neither subject was strictly relevant to the purpose of the present collection, it seemed better to reprint the narrative rather than the letters in the case of these sections also.
There is also a letter (published in the Eleventh Report of the Women's Armenian Relief Fund) from Miss Louie Bond to Mrs. Orpin, written on the 27th July, almost the eve of the evacuation but this, too, is practically entirely devoted to personal matters.
For the period of the retreat there are no contemporary letters, but only an undated memorandum by Miss Knapp, which agrees word for word with the latter part of her present narrative, from the beginning of the section headed "Flight" to the end.
THE SETTING OF THE DRAMA AND THE ACTORS THEREIN.
Van was one of the most beautiful cities of Asiatic Turkey---a city of
gardens and vineyards, situated on Lake Van in the centre of a plateau bordered
by magnificent mountains. The walled city, containing the shops and most
of the public buildings, was dominated by Castle Rock, a huge rock rising
sheer from the plain, crowned with ancient battlements and fortifications,
and bearing on its lakeward face famous cuneiform inscriptions. The Gardens,
so-called because nearly every house had its garden or vineyard, extended
over four miles eastward from the walled city and were about two miles in width.
The inhabitants numbered fifty thousand, three-fifths of whom were Armenians,
two-fifths Turks. The Armenians were progressive and ambitious, and because
of their numerical strength and the proximity of Russia the revolutionary
party grew to be a force to be reckoned with. Three of its noted leaders
were Vremyan, member of the Ottoman Parliament ; Ishkhan, the one most
skilled in military tactics ; and Aram, of whom there will be much
to say later. The Governor often consulted with these men and seemed to
be on the most friendly terms with them.
The American Mission Compound was on the south-eastern border of the
middle third of the Gardens, on a slight rise of ground that made its buildings
somewhat conspicuous. These buildings were a church building, two large
new school buildings, two small ones, a lace school, a hospital, dispensary
and four missionary residences. South-east, and quite near, was a broad
plain. Here was the largest Turkish barracks of the large garrison, between
which and the American premises nothing intervened. North and nearer, but
with streets and houses between, was another large barracks, and farther
north, within rifle range, was Toprak-Kala Hill, surmounted by a small barracks
dubbed by the Americans the "Pepper Box." Five minutes' walk to
the east of us was the German Orphanage managed by Herr Spörri, his
wife and daughter (of Swiss extraction) and three single ladies.
The American force in 1914-1915 consisted of the veteran missionary,
Mrs. G. C. Raynolds (Dr. Raynolds had been in America a year and a half
collecting funds for our Van college, and had been prevented from returning
by the outbreak of war) ; Dr. Clarence D. Ussher, in charge of the
hospital and medical work; Mrs. Ussher, in charge of a philanthropic lace
industry; Mr. and Mrs. Ernest A. Yarrow, in charge of the Boys' School and
general work ; Miss Gertrude Rogers, principal of the Girls' School ;
Miss Caroline Silliman, in charge of the primary department, and two Armenian
and one Turkish kindergarten; Miss Elizabeth Ussher, in charge of the musical
department; Miss Louise Bond, the English superintendent of the hospital;
and Miss Grisel McLaren, our touring missionary. Dr. Ussher and Mr. Yarrow
had each four children; I was a visitor from Bitlis.
BETWEEN THE DEVIL AND THE DEEP SEA.
During the mobilization of the fall and winter the Armenians had been
ruthlessly plundered under the name of requisitioning; rich men were ruined
and the poor stripped. Armenian soldiers in the Turkish army were neglected,
half starved, set to digging trenches and doing the menial work ; but,
worst of all, they were deprived of their arms and thus left at the mercy
of their fanatical, age-long enemies, their Moslem fellow-soldiers. Small
wonder that those who could find a loophole of escape or could pay for exemption
from military duty did so; many of those who could do neither simply would
not give themselves up. We felt that a day of reckoning would soon come---a
collision between these opposing forces or a holy war. But the revolutionists
conducted themselves with remarkable restraint and prudence; controlled
their hot-headed youth ; patrolled the streets to prevent skirmishes ;
and bade the villagers endure in silence---better a. village or two burned
unavenged than that any attempt at reprisals should furnish an excuse for massacre.
For some time after Djevdet Bey, a brother-in-law of Enver Pasha, minister
of war, became Governor General of Van Vilayet, he was absent from the city
fighting at the border. When he returned in the early spring, everyone felt
there would soon be "something doing." There was. He demanded
from the Armenians 3,000 soldiers. So anxious were they to keep the peace
that they promised to accede to this demand. But at this juncture trouble
broke out between Armenians and Turks in the Shadakh region, and Djevdet
Bey requested Ishkhan to go there as peace commissioner, accompanied by
three other notable revolutionists. On their way there he had all four treacherously
murdered. This was Friday, the 16th April. He then summoned Vremyan to him
under the pretence of consulting with this leader, arrested him and sent him off to Constantinople.
The revolutionists now felt that they could not trust Djevdet Bey, the
Vali, in any way and that therefore they could not give him the 3,000 men.
They told him they would give 400 and pay by degrees the exemption tax for
the rest. He would not accept the compromise. The Armenians begged Dr. Ussher
and Mr. Yarrow to see Djevdet Bey and try to mollify him. The Vali was obdurate.
He "must be obeyed." He would put down this "rebellion"
at all costs. He would first punish Shadakh, then attend to Van, but if
the rebels fired one shot meanwhile he would put to death every man, woman and child of the Christians.
The fact cannot be too strongly emphasized that there was no "rebellion."
As already pointed out, the revolutionists meant to keep the peace if it
lay in their power to do so. But for some time past a line of Turkish entrenchments
had been secretly drawn round the Armenian quarter of the Gardens. The revolutionists,
determined to sell their lives as dearly as possible, prepared a defensive line of entrenchments.
Djevdet Bey said he wished to send a guard of fifty soldiers to the American
premises. This guard must be accepted or a written statement given him by
the Americans to the effect that it had been offered and refused, so that
he should be absolved from all responsibility for our safety. He wished
for an immediate answer, but at last consented to wait till Sunday noon.
Our Armenian friends, most of them, agreed that the guard must be accepted.
But the revolutionists declared that such a force in so central a location
menaced the safety of the Armenian forces and that they would never permit
it to reach our premises alive. We might have a guard of five. But Djevdet
Bey would give us fifty or none. Truly we were between the devil and the
deep sea, for, if both revolutionists and Vali kept their word, we should
be the occasion for the outbreak of trouble, if the guard were sent ;
if it were not sent, we should have no official assurance of safety for
the thousands who were already preparing to take refuge on our premises.
We should be blamed for an unhappy outcome either way. On Monday, when Dr.
Ussher saw the Vali again, he seemed to be wavering and asked if he should
send the guard. Dr. Ussher left the decision with him, but added that the
sending of such a force might precipitate trouble. It was never sent.
Meanwhile Djevdet Bey had asked Miss McLaren and Schwester Martha, who
had been nursing in the Turkish military hospital all winter, to continue
their work there, and they had consented.
WAR! "ISHIM YOK, KEIFIM TCHOK."
On Tuesday, the 20th April, at 6 a.m., some Turkish soldiers tried to
seize one of a band of village women on their way to the city. She fled.
Two Armenian soldiers came up and asked the Turks what they were doing.
The Turkish soldiers fired on the Armenians, killing them. Thereupon the
Turkish entrenchments opened fire. The siege had begun. There was a steady
rifle firing all day, and from the walled city, now cut off from communication
with the Gardens, was heard a continuous cannonading from Castle Rock upon
the houses below. In the evening, houses were seen burning in every direction.
All the Armenians in the Gardens---nearly 30,000, as the Armenian population
of the walled city is small---were now gathered into a district about a
mile square, protected by eighty "teerks" (manned and barricaded
houses) besides walls and trenches. The Armenian force consisted of 1,500
trained riflemen possessing only about 300 rifles. Their supply of ammunition
was not great, so they were very sparing of it ; used pistols only,
when they could, and employed all sorts of devices to draw the fire of the
enemy and waste their ammunition. They began to make bullets and cartridges,
turning out 2,000 a day ; also gunpowder, and after awhile they made
three mortars for throwing bombs. The supply of material for the manufacture
of these things was limited, and methods and implements were crude and primitive,
but they were very happy and hopeful and exultant over their ability to
keep the enemy at bay. Some of the rules for their men were : Keep
clean; do not drink ; tell the truth ; do not curse the religion
of the enemy. They sent a manifesto to the Turks to the effect that their
quarrel was with one man and not with their Turkish neighbours. Valis might
come and go, but the two races must continue to live together, and they
hoped that after Djevdet went there might be peaceful and friendly relations
between them. The Turks answered in the same spirit, saying that they were
forced to fight. Indeed, a protest against this war was signed by many prominent
Turks, but Djevdet would pay no attention to it.
The Armenians took and burned (the inmates, however, escaping) the barracks
north of our premises, but apart from this they did not attempt the offensive
to any extent---their numbers were too few. They were fighting for their
homes, their very lives, and our sympathies could not but be wholly on their
side, though we strove to keep our actions neutral. We allowed no armed
men to enter the premises, and their leader, Aram, in order to help us to
preserve the neutrality of our premises, forbade the bringing of wounded
soldiers to our hospital, though Dr. Ussher treated them at their own temporary
hospital. But Djevdet Bey wrote to Dr. Ussher on the 23rd that armed men
had been seen entering our premises and that the rebels had prepared entrenchments
near us. If, at the time of attack, one shot were fired from these entrenchments,
he would be "regretfully compelled" to turn his cannon upon our
premises and completely destroy them. We might know this for a surety. We
answered that we were preserving the neutrality of our premises by every
means m our power. By no law could we be held responsible for the actions
of individuals or organisations outside our premises.
Our correspondence with the Vali was carried on through our official
representative, Signor Sbordone, the Italian consular agent, and our postman
was an old woman bearing a flag of truce. On her second journey she fell
into a ditch and, rising without her white flag, was instantly shot dead
by Turkish soldiers. Another was found, but she was wounded while sitting
at the door of her shack on our premises. Then Aram said that he would permit
no further correspondence until the Vali should answer a letter of Sbordone's,
in which the latter had told Djevdet that he had no right to expect the
Armenians to surrender now, since the campaign had taken on the character
of a massacre.
Djevdet would permit no communication with Miss McLaren at the Turkish
hospital, and would answer no question of ours concerning her welfare, though
after two weeks he wrote to Herr Spörri that she and Schwester Martha
were well and comfortable. Dr. Ussher had known the Vali as a boy and had
always been on the most friendly terms with him, but in a letter to the
Austrian banker who had taken refuge on the German premises, the Vali wrote
that one of his officers had taken some Russian prisoners and cannon and
that he would cause them to parade in front of "His Majesty Dr. Ussher's
fortifications, so that he, who with the rebels was always awaiting the
Russians, should see them and be content." This letter ended with the
words: "Ishim yok, keifim tchok" ("I have no work and much
fun.") While he was having no work and much fun, his soldiers and their
wild allies, the Kurds, were sweeping the countryside, massacring men, women,
and children and burning their homes. Babies were shot in their mothers'
arms, small children were horribly mutilated, women were stripped and beaten.
The villages were not prepared for attack ; many made no resistance ;
others resisted until their ammunition gave out. On Sunday, the 25th, the
first band of village refugees came to the city. At early dawn we heard
them knocking, knocking, knocking at our gate. Dr. Ussher went out in dressing
gown and slippers to hear their pitiful tale and send the wounded to the
hospital, where he worked over them all day.
THE MISSION'S FIRST-AID TO THE INJURED.
Six thousand people from the Gardens had early removed to our premises
with all their worldly possessions, filling church and school buildings
and every room that could possibly be spared in the missionary residences.
One woman said to Miss Silliman:
"What would we do without this place ? This is the third massacre
during which I have taken refuge here." A large proportion of these
people had to be fed, as they had been so poor that they had bought daily
from the ovens what bread they had money for, and now that resource was
cut off. Housing, sanitation, government, food, relation with the revolutionist
forces, were problems that required great tact and executive ability. The
Armenians were not able to cope with these problems unaided. They turned
to the missionaries for help.
Mr. Yarrow has a splendid gift for organisation. He soon had everything
in smoothly running order, with everyone hard at work at what he was best
fitted to do. A regular city government for the whole city of thirty thousand
inhabitants was organised with mayor, judges, and police---the town had
never been so well policed before. Committees were formed to deal with every
possible contingency. Grain was sold or contributed to the common fund by
those who possessed it, most of whom manifested a generous and self-sacrificing
spirit; one man gave all the wheat he possessed except a month's supply
for his family. The use of a public oven was secured, bread tickets issued,
a soup kitchen opened, and daily rations were given out to those on our
premises and those outside who needed food. Miss Rogers and Miss Silliman
secured a daily supply of milk, and made some of their school-girls boil
it and distribute it to babies who needed it, until 190 were being thus
fed. The Boy Scouts, whom thirteen-year-old Neville Ussher had helped organize
in the fall, now did yeoman's service in protecting the buildings against
the dangers of fire, keeping the premises clean, carrying wounded on stretchers,
reporting the sick, and, during the fourth week, distributing milk and eggs
to babies and sick outside the premises.
Our hospital, which had a normal capacity of fifty beds, was made to
accommodate one hundred and sixty-seven, beds being borrowed and placed
on the floor in every available space. Such of the wounded as could walk
or be brought to the hospital came regularly to have their wounds dressed.
Many complicated operations were required to repair the mutilations inflicted
by an unimaginable brutality and love of torture. Dr. Ussher, as the only
physician and surgeon in the besieged city, had not only the care of the
patients in his hospital, the treatment of the wounded refugees and of the
wounded Armenian soldiers, but his dispensary and out-patients increased
to an appalling number. Among the refugees exposure and privation brought
in their train scores of cases of pneumonia and dysentery, and an epidemic
of measles raged among the children. Miss Silliman took charge of a measles
annex, Miss Rogers and Miss Ussher helped in the hospital, where Miss Bond
and her Armenian nurses were worked to the limit of their strength, and
after a while Mrs. Ussher, aided by Miss Rogers, opened an overflow hospital
in an Armenian school-house, cleared of refugees for the purpose. Here it
was a struggle to get beds, utensils, helpers, even food enough for the
patients. Indeed all this extra medical and surgical work was hampered by
insufficient medical and surgical supplies, for the annual shipment had
been stalled at Alexandretta.
DARK DAYS.
At the end of two weeks the people in the walled city managed to send
us word that they were holding their own and had taken some of the government
buildings, though they were only a handful of fighters and were cannonaded
day and night. About 16,000 cannon balls or shrapnel were fired upon them.
The old-fashioned balls sunk into the three-feet thick walls of sun-dried
brick without doing much harm. In time, of course, the walls would fall
in, but they were the walls of upper stories. People took refuge in the
lower stories, so only three persons lost their lives from this cause. Some
of the "teerks" in the Gardens were also cannonaded without much
damage being done. It seemed the enemy was reserving his heavier cannon
and his shrapnel till the last. Three cannon balls fell on our premises
the first week, one of them on a porch of the Usshers' house. Thirteen persons
were wounded by bullets on the premises, one fatally. Our premises were
so centrally located that the bullets of the Turks kept whizzing through,
entered several rooms, broke the tiles on the roofs, and peppered the outside
of the walls. We became so used to the pop-pop-pop of rifles and booming
of cannon that we paid little attention to them in the daytime, but the
fierce fusillades at night were rather nerve-racking.
A man escaping from Ardjish related the fate of that town, second in
size and importance to Van in the vilayet. The kaimakam. had called the
men of all the guilds together on the 19th April, and, as he had always
been friendly to the Armenians, they trusted him. When they had all gathered,
he had them mown down by his soldiers.
Many of the village refugees had stopped short of the city at the little
village of Shushantz, on a mountain side near the city. Here Aram bade them
remain. On the 8th May we saw the place in flames, and Varak Monastery near
by, with its priceless ancient manuscripts, also went up in smoke. These
villagers now flocked into the city. Djevdet seemed to have altered his
tactics. He had women and children driven in by hundreds to help starve
the city out. Owing to the mobilisation of the previous fall, the supply
of wheat in the Gardens had been very much less than usual to begin with,
and now that 10,000 refugees were being given a daily ration, though a ration
barely sufficient to sustain life, this supply was rapidly approaching its
limit. The ammunition was also giving out. Djevdet could bring in plenty
of men and ammunition from other cities. Unless help came from Russia, it
was impossible for the city to hold out much longer against him, and the
hope of such help seemed very faint.
We had no communication with the outside world; a telegram we had prepared
to send to our embassy before the siege never left the city ; the revolutionists
were constantly sending out appeals for help to the Russo-Armenian volunteers
on the border, but no word or sign of their reaching their destination was
received by us. At the very last, when the Turks should come to close quarters,
we knew that all the population of the besieged city would crowd into our
premises as a last hope. But, enraged as Djevdet was by this unexpected
and prolonged resistance, was it to be hoped that he could be persuaded
to spare the lives of one of these men, women and children ? We believed
not. He might offer the Americans personal safety if we would leave the
premises, but this, of course, we would not do; we would share the fate
of our people. And it seemed not at all improbable that he would not even
offer us safety, believing, as he seemed to believe, that we were aiding
and upholding the "rebels."
Those were dark days indeed. Our little American circle came together
two evenings in the week to discuss the problems constantly arising. We
would joke and laugh over some aspects of our situation, but as we listened
to the volley firing only two blocks away, we knew that at any hour the
heroic but weakening defence might be overpowered; knew that then hell would
be let loose in the crowded city and our crowded compound; knew that we
should witness unspeakable atrocities perpetrated on the persons of those
we loved, and probably suffer them in our own persons. And we. would sing:
"Peace, perfect peace ; the future all unknown
Jesus we know and He is on the throne,"
and pray to the God who was able to deliver us out of the very mouth
of the lion.
On Saturday forenoon a rift seemed to appear in the clouds, for many
ships were seen on the lake, sailing away from Van, and we heard that they
contained Turkish women and children. We became a "city all gone up
to the housetops," wondering and surmising. Once before such a flight
had taken place, when the Russians had advanced as far as Sarai. They had
retreated, however, and the Turkish families had returned.
That afternoon the sky darkened again. Cannon at the Big Barracks on
the plain began to fire in our direction. At first we could not believe
that the shots were aimed at our flag, but no doubt was permitted us on
that point, Seven shells fell on the premises, one on the roof of Miss Rogers'
and Miss Silliman's house, making a big hole in it; two others did the same
thing on the boys'-school and girls'-school roofs. On Sunday morning the
bombardment began again. Twenty-six shells fell on the premises before noon.
When the heavy firing began Dr. Ussher was visiting patients outside
and Mrs. Ussher was also away from home at her overflow hospital, so I ran
over from our own hospital to take their children to the safest part of
the house, a narrow hall on the first floor. There we listened to the shrieking
of the shrapnel and awaited the bursting of each shell. A deafening explosion
shook the house. I ran up to my room to find it so full of dust and smoke
that I could not see a foot before me. A shell had come through the three-feet-thick
outside wall, burst, scattering its contained bullets, and its cap had passed
through a partition wall into the next room and broken a door opposite.
A shell entered a room in Mrs. Raynold's house, killing a little Armenian
girl. Ten more shells fell in the afternoon. Djevdet was fulfilling his
threat of bombarding our premises, and this proved to us that we could hope
for no mercy at his hands when he should take the city.
DELIVERANCE.
In this darkest hour of all came deliverance. A lull followed the cannonading.
Then at sunset a letter came from the occupants of the only Armenian house
within the Turkish lines which had been spared (this because Djevdet had
lived in it when a boy) which gave the information that the Turks had left
the city. The barracks on the summit and at the foot of Toprak-Kala were
found to contain so small a guard that it was easily overpowered, and these
buildings were burned amidst the wildest excitement. So with all the Turkish
"teerks," which were visited in turn. The Big Barracks was next
seen to disgorge its garrison, a large company of horsemen who rode away
over the hills, and that building, too, was burned after midnight. Large
stores of wheat and ammunition were found. It all reminded one of the seventh
chapter of II. Kings.
The whole city was awake, singing and rejoicing all night. In the morning
its inhabitants could go whither they would unafraid. And now came the first
check to our rejoicing. Miss McLaren was gone ! She and Schwester Martha
had been sent with the patients of the Turkish hospital four days before
to Bitlis.
Mr. Yarrow went to the hospital. He found there twenty-five wounded soldiers
too sick to travel, left there without food or water for five days. He found
unburied dead. He stayed all day in the horrible place, that his presence
might protect the terrified creatures until he could secure their removal
to our hospital.
On Wednesday, the 19th May, the Russians and Russo-Armenian volunteers
came into the city. It had been the knowledge of their approach that had
caused the Turks to flee. Some hard fighting had to be done in the villages,
however, before Djevdet and his reinforcements were driven out of the province.
Troops poured into the city from Russia and Persia and passed on towards
Bitlis.
Aram was made temporary governor of the province, and, for the first
time for centuries, Armenians were given a chance to govern themselves.
Business revived. People began to rebuild their burned houses and shops.
We re-opened our mission schools, except the school in the walled city,
the school-house there having been burned.
THE TABLES TURNED.
Not all the Turks had fled from the city. Some old men and women and
children had stayed behind, many of them in hiding. The Armenian soldiers,
unlike Turks, were not making war on such. There was only one place where
the captives could be safe from the rabble, however. In their dilemma the
Armenians turned, as usual, to the American missionaries. And so it came
to pass that hardly had the six thousand Armenian refugees left our premises
when the care of a thousand Turkish refugees was thrust upon us, some of
them from villages the Russo-Armenian volunteers were "cleaning out."
It was with the greatest difficulty that food could be procured for these
people. The city had an army to feed now. Wheat---the stores left by the
Turks---was obtainable, but no flour, and the use of a mill was not available
for some time. The missionaries had no help in a task so distasteful to
the Armenians except that of two or three of the teachers of the school
in the walled city, who now had no other work. Mr. Yarrow was obliged to
drop most of his other duties and spend practically all his time working
for our protégés. Mrs. Yarrow, Miss Rogers and Miss Silliman
administered medicines and tried to give every one of the poor creatures
a bath. Mrs. Ussher had bedding made, and secured and personally dispensed
milk to the children and sick, spending several hours daily among them.
The wild Cossacks considered the Turkish women legitimate prey, and though
the Russian General gave us a small guard, there was seldom a night during
the first two or three weeks in which Dr. Ussher and Mr. Yarrow did not
have to drive off marauders who had climbed over the walls of the compound
and eluded the guard.
The effect on its followers of the religion of Islam was never more strongly
contrasted with Christianity. While the Armenian refugees had been mutually
helpful and self-sacrificing, these Moslems showed themselves absolutely
selfish, callous and indifferent to each other's suffering. Where the Armenians
had been cheery and hopeful, and had clung to life with wonderful vitality,
the Moslems, with no faith in God and no hope of a future life, bereft now
of hope in this life, died like flies of the prevailing dysentery from lack
of stamina and the will to live.
The situation became intolerable. The missionaries begged the Russian
General to send these people out to villages, with a guard sufficient for
safety and flocks to maintain them until they could begin to get their living
from the soil. He was too much occupied with other matters to attend to
us.
After six weeks of this, Countess Alexandra Tolstoi (daughter of the
famous novelist) came to Van and took off our hands the care of our "guests,"
though they remained on our premises. She was a young woman, simple, sensible,
and lovable. We gave her a surprise party on her birthday, carrying her
the traditional cake with candles and crowning her with flowers, and she
declared she had never had a birthday so delightfully celebrated in all
her life. She worked hard for her charges. When her funds gave out and no
more were forthcoming and her Russian helpers fell ill, she succeeded where
we had failed and induced the General to send the Turks out into the country
with provision for their safety and sustenance.
THE PESTILENCE THAT WALKETH IN DARKNESS.
Our Turkish refugees cost us a fearful price.
The last day of June Mrs. Ussher took her children, who had whooping
cough, out of the pestilential atmosphere of the city to Artamid, the summer
home on Lake Van, nine miles away. Dr. Ussher went there for the week-end,
desperately in need of a little rest. On Saturday night they both became
very ill. Upon hearing of this I went down to take care of them. On Monday
Mr. and Mrs. Yarrow also fell ill. Ten days yet remained till the time set
for closing the hospital for the summer, but Miss Bond set her nurses to
the task of sending the patients away and went over to nurse the Yarrows.
This left me without help for five days. Then, for four days more, two Armenian
nurses cared for the sick ones at night and an untrained man nurse helped
me during the daytime. Miss Rogers had come down on Thursday, the day after
commencement, for the cure of what she believed to be an attack of malaria.
On Friday she too fell ill. Fortunately, there was at last a really good
Russian physician in town, and he was most faithful in his attendance. The
sickness proved to be typhus Later we learned that at about the same time
Miss Silliman, who had left for America on her furlough on the 15th June,
accompanied by Neville Ussher, had been ill at Tiflis with what we now know
was a mild form of the same disease. Dr. Ussher might have contracted it
from his outside patients, but the others undoubtedly contracted it from the Turkish refugees.
Mrs. Yarrow was dangerously ill, but passed her crisis safely and first
of all. Miss Bond then came to Artamid, though Mr. Yarrow was still very
ill, feeling that the Usshers needed her more on account of their distance
from the doctor. Miss Ussher took charge of the Yarrow children up in Van; Mrs. Raynolds managed the business affairs of the mission.
Mrs. Ussher had a very severe form of the disease, and her delicate frame,
worn out with the overwork and terrible strain of the months past, could
make no resistance. On the 14th July she entered into the life eternal.
We dared not let the sick ones suspect what had happened. Dr. Ussher
was too ill at the time and for more than two weeks longer to be told of
his terrible loss. For three months preceding his illness he had been the
only physician in Van, and the strain of over-work and sleeplessness told
severely now. After he had passed his typhus crisis, his life was in danger
for a week longer from the pneumonia which had been a complication from
the first. Then followed another not infrequent complication of typhus,
an abscess in the parotid gland which caused long-continued weakness and
suffering, at one time threatened life and reason, and has had serious consequences
which may prove permanent. Mr. Yarrow was so ill that his life was quite
despaired of. It was by a veritable miracle that he was restored to us.
FLIGHT.
Meanwhile the Russian army had been slowly advancing westward. It had
not been uniformly successful as we had expected it to be. Indeed, the Russians
seemed to fight sluggishly and unenthusiastically. The Russo-Armenian volunteers,
who were always sent ahead of the main army, did the heavy fighting. By
the last week of July the Russians had not yet taken Bitlis, only ninety
miles distant from Van. Suddenly the Turkish army began to advance towards
Van, and the Russian army to retreat.
On Friday, the 30th July, General Nicolaieff ordered all the Armenians of the Van province, also the Americans and other foreigners, to flee for their lives. By Saturday night the city was nearly emptied of Armenians and quite emptied of conveyances. Nearly all our teachers, nurses, employees had left. It was every man for himself and no one to help us secure carriages or horses for our own flight. We at Artamid, with a sick man to provide for, would have had great difficulty in getting up to the city in time, had not Mrs. Yarrow risen from her sick-bed to go to the General and beg him to send us ambulances. These reached us after midnight.
There was little question in our minds as to our own flight. Our experience
during the siege had shown us that the fact of our being Americans would
not protect us from the Turks. Had not our two men, Mr. Yarrow and Dr. Ussher,
been absolutely helpless we might have debated the matter. As it was, we
women could not assume the responsibility of staying and keeping them there,
and even if we had stayed we could have found no means to live in a deserted city.
We were fifteen Americans and had ten Armenian dependents ---women and
children---to provide for. The head nurse of the hospital, Garabed, plucky
and loyal little fellow that he was, had sent on his mother and wife and
had remained behind to help us get out of the country. Dr. Ussher's man-cook,
having been with us at Artamid when the panic began, had been unable to
secure conveyance for his sick wife. We greatly needed his help on the journey,
but. this involved our providing for a third sick person. We had three horses,
an American grocer's delivery cart, really not strong enough for heavy work
on rough and mountainous roads, and a small cart that would seat three. Our two other carts were not usable.
We begged the General to give us ambulances. He absolutely refused---he
had none to spare. But, he added, he was to be replaced in a day or two
by General Trokin ; we could appeal to him when he came; the danger
was not immediate. Somewhat reassured and not knowing how we could manage
without help from the Russians, we made no effort to leave that day. But
the next day, Monday, we heard that the volunteers who were trying to keep
the road open to Russia would not be able to do so much longer---there was no time to lose. We set to work.
One of cur teachers who had not succeeded in getting away before Monday
morning, kindly took a small bag of clothing on his ox-cart for each of
us. We spread the quilts and blankets we should need on the way on the bottom
of the delivery cart, intending to lay our three sick people on these. Garabed,
who had never driven a team in his life, must drive two of our horses in
this cart. Mrs. Raynolds would drive the third horse harnessed to the small
cart, and take the babies and what food there was possibly room for; no
provisions could be bought on the way. The rest of us must walk, though
Mrs. Yarrow and Miss Rogers were newly risen from a sick bed and the children
were all under. twelve. We put loads on the cows we must take with us for
the sake of the babies and the patients. But the cows were refractory; they
kicked off the loads and ran wildly about the yard, tails up, heads down,
whereupon the single horse broke loose and "also ran," smashing the small car